Back to 11.2 Fairness in Voting Methods

11.2 Exercise 7

Avg difficulty 2.5

Let’s return to the survey about tax refund spending from the example. We know that the Condorcet criterion applies because Option D, “Pay off debt,” is a Condorcet candidate, which wins every pairwise match up.

Use the information in the ballot summary from the table below to find the winner and determine whether the Condorcet criterion is satisfied in this election when each of the following voting methods are used.

Votes 33 32 31 4
On a vacation (V) 1 3 3 2
Put into savings (S) 3 1 2 1
Pay off debt (D) 2 2 1 4
Other (T) 4 4 4 3
  1. Plurality
  2. Ranked-choice voting
  3. Borda count

OpenStax Contemporary Mathematics, 11.2 Fairness in Voting Methods, exercise 7

AI Tutor

Adapted from Contemporary Mathematics © 2023 Rice University. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Source: Contemporary Mathematics. Imported at revision fa7c1a1.