Other logical notions
Sorting sentences into necessary truths, necessary falsehoods and contingencies, judging which collections are jointly possible, and finding examples to fit each combination.
3 exercises
Exercise A
For each of the following: Is it necessarily true, necessarily false, or contingent?
-
Caesar crossed the Rubicon.
-
Someone once crossed the Rubicon.
-
No one has ever crossed the Rubicon.
-
If Caesar crossed the Rubicon, then someone has.
-
Even though Caesar crossed the Rubicon, no one has ever crossed the Rubicon.
-
If anyone has ever crossed the Rubicon, it was Caesar.
Exercise E
Consider the following sentences:
-
There are at least four giraffes at the wild animal park.
-
There are exactly seven gorillas at the wild animal park.
-
There are not more than two Martians at the wild animal park.
-
Every giraffe at the wild animal park is a Martian.
Now consider each of the following collections of sentences. Which are jointly possible? Which are jointly impossible?
-
Sente…
Exercise G
Which of the following is possible? If it is possible, give an example. If it is not possible, explain why.
-
A valid argument that has one false premise and one true premise
-
A valid argument that has a false conclusion
-
A valid argument, the conclusion of which is a necessary falsehood
-
An invalid argument, the conclusion of which is a necessary truth
-
A necessary truth that is contingent
-
…
Adapted from forall x: Calgary © 2025 P. D. Magnus, Tim Button, Robert Trueman, and Richard Zach. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Source: forall x: Calgary. Imported at revision ec34df8.