Definite descriptions
Symbolizing 'the F' via Russell's analysis — existence, uniqueness, predication — and weighing it against alternative readings of description claims.
4 exercises
Exercise A
Using the following symbolization key:
- domain:
people
- :
knows the combination to the safe
- :
is a spy
- :
is a vegetarian
- :
trusts
- :
Hofthor
- :
Ingmar
symbolize the following sentences in FOL:
-
Hofthor trusts a vegetarian.
-
Everyone who trusts Ingmar trusts a vegetarian.
-
Everyone who trusts Ingmar trusts someone who trusts a vegetarian.
-
Only Ingmar knows the combination to the s…
Exercise B
Using the following symbolization key:
- domain:
cards in a standard deck
- :
is black
- :
is a club
- :
is a deuce
- :
is a jack
- :
is a man with an axe
- :
is one-eyed
- :
is wild
symbolize each sentence in FOL:
-
All clubs are black cards.
-
There are no wild cards.
-
There are at least two clubs.
-
There is more than one one-eyed jack.
-
There are at most two one-eyed jacks.
-
There are…
Exercise C
Using the following symbolization key:
- domain:
animals in the world
- :
is in Farmer Brown’s field
- :
is a horse
- :
is a Pegasus
- :
has wings
symbolize the following sentences in FOL:
-
There are at least three horses in the world.
-
There are at least three animals in the world.
-
There is more than one horse in Farmer Brown’s field.
-
There are three horses in Farmer Brown’s field.
-
The…
Exercise D
In this chapter, we symbolized ‘Nick is the traitor’ by ‘’. Explain why these would be equally good symbolisations:
Adapted from forall x: Calgary © 2025 P. D. Magnus, Tim Button, Robert Trueman, and Richard Zach. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Source: forall x: Calgary. Imported at revision ec34df8.